A testosterone check might uncover something you weren't looking for. But an unexpected prostate blood test result doesn't automatically mean cancer.
By Nick Brennan · Last revised:
November 2026
You go in to get your testosterone checked. Then someone tells you there's something unusual about your prostate bloodwork.
If you're in your 20s or 30s, that's probably not a conversation you expected to have. You might not have given your prostate much thought at all, especially if nothing's been bothering you.
That's happened at Gameday Men's Health, where men coming in to have their testosterone checked are also offered a free prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test.
According to Gameday founder and CEO Evan Miller, those additional tests have sometimes uncovered concerning results in men as young as their 20s and 30s. He also recalls cases where further investigation ultimately led to prostate cancer diagnoses.
You Came In for Testosterone. What Else Might They Find?
A lot of men are interested in getting their testosterone checked. Maybe their energy has dropped, their sex drive isn't what it used to be, or they're simply curious about where their levels stand.
But the number they're interested in isn't necessarily the only thing worth paying attention to.
High blood pressure and elevated cholesterol are good examples. Both can develop long before someone feels noticeably unhealthy, and both can increase the risk of serious health problems down the road.
Miller says most men aren't walking into Gameday asking for preventative screening. They're coming because they want to know about their testosterone or improve something specific about how they feel.
And that's part of what makes the visit an opportunity to talk about their health more broadly. They've come in for something they're interested in, but there may be other things worth looking at while they're there.
Aren't You Supposed to Wait Until You're Older?
For most men, prostate cancer screening doesn't become a routine recommendation until middle age. The American Cancer Society's updated guidelines recommend PSA testing every two years for men between 50 and 69, with some higher-risk men starting at 45.
So why isn't everyone getting tested at 25 or 30?
One reason is simply how rare prostate cancer is at those ages. PSA testing can find cancer before it causes symptoms, but it can also flag something unusual when cancer isn't present. And when prostate cancer is that uncommon, more men can end up getting additional tests that ultimately don't find cancer.
There's another consideration that might surprise you. Even when testing does uncover cancer, immediate treatment isn't always necessary. Some prostate cancers grow so slowly that doctors recommend monitoring them closely rather than going straight to surgery or radiation. It's called active surveillance, and it involves regular testing to watch for signs that the cancer is becoming more aggressive.
None of that makes an unexpected cancer diagnosis in a younger man any less important. For someone who discovers a serious problem because of a PSA test, that finding could make an enormous difference. But as important as those discoveries are, they don't necessarily tell us when routine screening should begin for everyone.
A High PSA Doesn't Automatically Mean Cancer
Imagine you're 32, feeling perfectly healthy, and someone tells you your PSA came back elevated.
It's understandable if your mind immediately goes to prostate cancer. After all, that's probably the only reason you've ever heard anyone talk about PSA testing. But PSA isn't a cancer-specific measurement. It's a protein produced by your prostate, and several things besides cancer can cause more of it to show up in your bloodstream.
Prostate inflammation or infection can raise PSA. So can an enlarged prostate, although that's much more common as men get older. Even recent ejaculation or certain activities, including vigorous cycling, can temporarily affect the reading.
That's why an elevated PSA isn't a diagnosis.
There isn't one number that automatically means you have cancer, or that you definitely don't. Your age and medical history matter, and doctors have to consider those things when interpreting the result. In many cases, the next step is simply to repeat the blood test after some time has passed. If it remains elevated, a urologist may recommend additional testing to figure out why.
Sometimes that investigation uncovers something serious. Other times, there's a much less concerning explanation. The important thing is to follow up without assuming the worst before you actually know what the result means.
Your Age Isn't the Whole Story
Deciding whether to get a test isn't the same as deciding what to do when a test comes back with an unusual result. Before the test, the question is whether it's likely to tell you something useful. Once you've got an unexpected result, the question becomes whether it needs a closer look. And being young doesn't automatically answer either one.
If you're experiencing urinary problems, blood in your urine, or other concerning changes, you shouldn't assume you're too young to have them evaluated. That doesn't automatically mean you need a PSA test, but it does mean the usual screening schedule shouldn't determine whether you speak with your doctor.
If they recommend another test, it's worth asking what they're looking for and what the result might actually tell you. And if something unusual does turn up, ask what else might explain it, whether the test needs to be repeated, and what happens next.
You don't need to go looking for every possible health problem. But you also don't need to be a certain age before taking a genuine concern seriously.
About the Expert: Evan Miller is the founder and CEO of Gameday Men's Health, a network of clinics specializing in testosterone replacement and other men's health services. His observations about PSA testing and men's attitudes toward preventative healthcare helped inform this essay.
What Actually Affects Testosterone Levels?
Testosterone can change with sleep, weight, exercise, illness, medications, age, and more, so one low result or a few symptoms don’t necessarily mean low T.
Can Sleep Apnea Affect Your Erections?
Sleep apnea may contribute to erection problems, but treating it can still matter even if your erections don’t noticeably improve.
What to Know Before Starting TRT
Before starting TRT, make sure low testosterone actually fits what you’re experiencing, know what you want treatment to change, and understand the fertility, treatment, and follow-up tradeoffs.
Getting Fitter Doesn’t Make Sex Better Right Away
A fitness push can be good for your health overall while temporarily making libido or erections feel worse if you’re training hard, eating less, and barely recovering.
Can Poor Sleep Affect Your Erections?
Poor sleep can affect your erections in more ways than one, especially when fatigue, lower arousal, disrupted morning wood, or sleep apnea become part of the pattern.
Can Exercise Improve Your Erections?
Regular cardio can gradually make it easier to get and stay hard by helping your heart and blood vessels work better.
